Our Full Menu
Monday to Thursday 7:30am to 6:00pm
Friday 7:30am to 11:00pm
Early Bird Dinner M/F 4:00 to 6:00pm
Saturday 7:30am to 4:00pm
& 7:00pm to 11:00pm
Ask about private functions on Sunday
Sandwiches, Wraps & Salads
Includes a cup of Amish ice cream or a side dish
Florida Avenue Special 7.50
Salami, pepperoni, Lebanon bologna & provolone -- very hearty!
Unique Turkey Club 7.50
Troyer's Turkey breast & Troyer's bacon, served with fresh lettuce & tomatoes, topped with mayo.
Lacey Swiss-n-Ham 6.00
Kickin' Turkey 6.00
Smoked turkey & hot pepper cheese
Village Veggie Delight 6.00
Veggie farmer's cheese & spring mix
MGM Special 6.00
Pastrami & mozzarella
Horsin' Around 6.00
Roast beef, horseradish cheese & horseradish sauce
Country Boy 6.00
Garlic bologna & Colby cheese
Troyer's Reuben 7.50
Troyer's corned beef & Swiss, Amish Wedding sauerkraut & slaw dressing on fresh rye bread
Homemade Chicken Salad 7.50
Troyer's white breast chicken, red sweet relish, banana pepper rings & garlic pickles, blended for taste and texture
Design your own 6.00
Select any one Amish deli meat & one cheese & choose the fixings to suit your mood.
Hot Diggity Dog 6.00
Two all beef hot dogs on a large homemade bun with or without sauerkraut
Pulled Pork 7.50
Served on a grilled bun with your choice of cheese
Fried Bologna 5.50
All beef bologna fried like Mama used to
Sandwich Bread Selections
Amish Breads
Wheat, white, sourdough, multi-grain, seedless & rye
Flavored Wraps
Sun-dried tomato, wheat, white & spinach
Etceteras
Side dishes 2.00
Macaroni salad, potato salad, coleslaw or fruit cup
Amish Soup of the Day 3.00
Sandwich Fixings: Lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, spring greens, spinach, mayonnaise & assorted Amish mustards and dressings.
Extra meat 2.00
Extra cheese 1.00
Extra veggies or relishes .50 each
Fresh Baked Goods & Goodies
Dressed Bagel 2.00
With Amish butter, jams & jellies
Undressed Bagel au naturale 1.50
Bagels by the dozen 11.00
Country Bagel 2.00
With homemade flavored cream cheeses
Unique Bagel 5.00
Fixed your way with Amish deli meat & cheese
Pies by the slice 3.00
Shoofly pie
Ask about today's other selections
Whole pies are available
Amish Ice Cream cup 2.00
Over 20 flavors! ½ gal. 6.75
Unique Specialty Hot Drinks
Decaf available upon request
Espresso 2.25
Espresso roast, expertly brewed
Cappuccino 2.95
Espresso with steamed milk, topped with a cap of foam
Caffé Latté 2.95
Espresso with steamed milk
Caffé Mocha 3.95
Espresso with steamed milk & chocolate, topped with whipped cream
Turtle Mocha 3.95
Espresso with steamed milk, dark chocolate & caramel, topped with whipped cream
Unique Latté 3.95
Espresso with steamed milk, dark chocolate, vanilla & caramel, topped with whipped cream and sprinkles
Florida Avenue Indulgence 3.95
Espresso with steamed milk, almond roca & raspberry, topped with a cap of foam
Fresh brewed coffee & sm 1.50
Flavored coffee of the week lg 1.75
Bottomless cup 2.00
Torani syrup flavor shots .50
Coffee by the pound 11.00
Other Beverages
Bottled Water 1.00
Unique Canned Sodas 1.50
Specialty Bottled Sodas 2.00
Italian Sodas 1.50
Frappes, Freezes & Frozen Fun Drinks
All drinks are blended with coffe, ice and
milk & topped with whipped cream
Maria's Tiramisu Freeze 4.95
Our house special signature drink
Iced Latté 2.95
We add a shot of espresso to the mix
Iced Cappuccino/Fabulous Frappe 3.95
Heath-Mocha, Peanut-Butter, Kona-Mocha, Cookies ‘n' Cream, White Chocolate, Vanilla Latte, Coco-Mocha-Nut, Caramel, Extream Toffee, Hazelnut or Java-Chip
Add an extra shot of espresso 1.00
Hot & Iced Teas to Please
Big Train Smoothie Blast 3.95
Blueberry, Mango-Guava, Pineapple-Coconut or Strawberry
Big Train Chai 2.95
Latté style, an additional 50¢
Assorted Hot Teas 1.50
Iced Teas Plain & Assorted Flavors 1.50
Cider Freeze 2.95
Apple, Blackberry, Blueberry & Cherry
Come browse around our Amish market.
We carry a wide selection of fresh meats and cheeses, sliced to order.
In addition, we offer a large variety of old-fashioned canned goods,
butters, baked goods, condiments, relishes, mustards
and a lot more...
While you are here,
visit our design center.